Build Your Writing Platform
Without Abandoning Your Writing › Forums › Critique Groups › [SCC] Rule 1, Exercise 1 › The Temp
This topic contains 12 replies, has 7 voices, and was last updated by Christy Zigweid 10 years, 10 months ago.
-
AuthorPosts
-
June 5, 2014 at 8:53 am #3707
You nailed it, Amanda! I’ve never been even a short-term temp, but you made me understand what it feels like to be the invisible long-serving member of a closed community. Nearly three years and nobody knows her name. Not even the reader.
She doesn’t get the memos (she’s only a temp) so everything she does is out of step, from casual Thursdays to the baseball game. You made my heart bleed for her. And then, of course, her own heart bleeds, into a bottle because she doesn’t even have her own trash can.
No one seems to know if she lived or died out there in the parking lot. What a sad ending.
You are a very effective writer and this is a story that grabbed me. A good job of showing how it feels to be on the outside looking in.
The story could be pared down a little. As an editor I’m always stumbling over extra words. But all in all, a very good job.
Judith
-
June 6, 2014 at 11:08 am #3772
Thanks so much Judith for reading my story and giving such great feedback. Somehow you summarized my story exactly how I meant it to be read!!! You really “hit the nail on the head” as a reader and critic. π I don’t know if I could have summarized it better myself. And if you have any tips on pairing down words or the editing side of things at all, please let me me know. I REALLY want to grow in that area.
Thanks again for your encouragement!
Amanda
-
-
June 6, 2014 at 1:18 pm #3779
You really described the office “life”.
I loved the rhythm of this sentence: “One day, someday, maybe soon, I could get company e-mails or a name badge and access code all my own too.”
The paragraph that started with “She is tall and thin” = that kind of jarred me a bit, not sure if it was the change in tense or just the description, it took me out of the story for a moment (but I got right back into it).
Well done – can’t wait to read more.
Scared to death, clueless and wondering if I should just crawl back under the covers and forget this writing thingβ¦.
-
June 7, 2014 at 4:18 am #3821
Thanks Jyl,
I appreciate the feedback. There is something about the tall and thin line that doesn’t quite mesh with the sentence. I had something else written there and took it out and probably should have changed that part up a bit too. Thanks again.
-Amanda
-
-
June 6, 2014 at 8:52 pm #3804
Utterly accurate. This kind of thing makes me shudder with empathy! π Just one small word of caution is to watch the perspective-switch. It went back and forth between her POV and narrative POV without any transition, and it threw me just a couple of times. But yow, I really liked this. I also want those shoes. π Thanks so much for sharing it!
-
June 7, 2014 at 4:21 am #3822
Thanks for the feedback and advice Ruthanne! Those POV switches can sneak up behind you so easily if your not watching your back…ha
-
June 10, 2014 at 6:05 pm #3979
My first published novel is present-tense, and those tenses were the hardest thing to keep straight during editing. π I feel your pain!
-
-
June 7, 2014 at 2:17 pm #3834
Hey James, its always fun when someone can relate to your story π I enjoyed hearing your experience as a temp. It is kind of comical in a strange way. I think since the situation the temp is in is sooooo bad, all you can do is laugh at the ridiculousness of it all. Thanks for the advice on how to make it more concise. I always welcome editing tips!
-
June 7, 2014 at 4:57 pm #3848
We think there are a lot of people in temp jobs and even full time employees who feel ignored and not fully accepted and this story portrays that feeling down to a tee.
We really liked the plot and the twist in the end, as now no-one will ever know “The Temp”.
One thing to improve is that the narrative chops and changes between “The Temp” and third person and this could be done a little more seamlessly.
-
June 7, 2014 at 6:24 pm #3861
Thanks Lord and Lady Nutt for the feedback. I am glad you enjoyed the story. I appreciate the advice too on the narrative changes!
-
-
June 10, 2014 at 11:40 pm #3988
Great story. I loved the ending. It was something I didn’t expect at all. Your descriptive writing is very good and you hit it on the head with making a person feel in the character’s shoes. My only improvement would be to watch the POV changes.
-
June 7, 2014 at 4:28 am #3823
Amanda – This is a great story. This certainly resonates with me in so many ways.
A couple of years ago, myself and another person, were hired to help install a new computer system meant to deal with the Affordable Care Act at an insurance company (I work for an IT Consulting Company). My friend and I were there for almost eight months – in a little room that was actually a converted vault. People almost never came back to talk to us, no one ever invited us to lunch, and a couple of times (I am not kidding) we were locked in building with the alarm turned on because people left to go home and they forgot we were back there.
We would often joke that if one us died in the vault, it was the responsibility of the other person to call someone, because otherwise no one would ever find us.
I’m sure you didn’t mean this story to be a funny one, but I chuckled a few times reading it because it was so accurate to me.
Just a suggestion – I think that there were places where you could probably leave out some items to streamline the story just a bit. You would tighten up the story and lose nothing that would make the story any less vibrant.
For Example:
You could spot her enthusiasm from a mile away like a sore thumb hit with a hammer. Coincidentally this place of work in which she so temporarily resided was, of all things, a homebuilding company. Yet a home of her own she will never be able to build or afford at her temporary pay rate. The work she does is that of an administrative assistant, but her official title remains absent. She still remains known now as just βThe Temp.This is a great detail – but if I don’t know what company she works for, it still doesn’t make it any less readable. It just seemed to read a bit rough to me. If you really like it you might try to weave along with something else in the story.
Really great – I really enjoyed reading this.
James Schmidt (J.L.S.)
James Lee Schmidt
-
AuthorPosts
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.